Baseline score 34.7/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 26.7/100 — not selected. Model judgement adjusted the score by -8.0: Submission lacks a coherent problem description or actionable detail, so it cannot be treated as a genuine product candidate.
Origin
contributor
Problem
1 submission grouped by the deterministic clustering layer. Reported as: "put your details about your name and eeverything make a tab for yourself". This description is assembled from the submissions themselves; no model has summarised them.
Submissions
1
Contributors
1
Score
26.7126
Decided by
claude-sonnet-5
▸Raw rejection
{
"id": "01a01eaa-e161-7000-8b90-95f91df61cd0",
"title": "Unclear Feedback Submission",
"problem": "1 submission grouped by the deterministic clustering layer. Reported as: \"put your details about your name and eeverything make a tab for yourself\". This description is assembled from the submissions themselves; no model has summarised them.",
"status": "rejected",
"risk": "medium",
"memberCount": 1,
"uniqueContributorCount": 1,
"evidenceWeight": "0.0000",
"lastActivityAt": "2026-08-20T10:15:17.381Z",
"origin": "contributor",
"decision": {
"id": "01a01eaa-fc73-760c-99c8-85f2fa267370",
"kind": "reject_proposal",
"outcome": "rejected",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 34.7/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 26.7/100 — not selected. Model judgement adjusted the score by -8.0: Submission lacks a coherent problem description or actionable detail, so it cannot be treated as a genuine product candidate.",
"totalScore": "26.7126",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"modelId": "claude-sonnet-5",
"decisionMethod": null,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-20T10:15:17.362Z"
}
}
Baseline score 34.7/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 22.7/100 — not selected. Model judgement adjusted the score by -12.0; its written explanation is withheld because it contained model output scaffolding rather than public copy.
Origin
contributor
Problem
1 submission grouped by the deterministic clustering layer. Reported as: "do something". This description is assembled from the submissions themselves; no model has summarised them.
Submissions
1
Contributors
1
Score
22.7126
Decided by
claude-sonnet-5
▸Raw rejection
{
"id": "01a01ea1-ea52-7000-ad0c-8ddd38f4e873",
"title": "Insufficient Feedback Submitted",
"problem": "1 submission grouped by the deterministic clustering layer. Reported as: \"do something\". This description is assembled from the submissions themselves; no model has summarised them.",
"status": "rejected",
"risk": "medium",
"memberCount": 1,
"uniqueContributorCount": 1,
"evidenceWeight": "0.0000",
"lastActivityAt": "2026-08-20T10:05:29.771Z",
"origin": "contributor",
"decision": {
"id": "01a01ea2-0516-725d-ba63-6c027b1407b7",
"kind": "reject_proposal",
"outcome": "rejected",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 34.7/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 22.7/100 — not selected. Model judgement adjusted the score by -12.0; its written explanation is withheld because it contained model output scaffolding rather than public copy.",
"totalScore": "22.7126",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"modelId": "claude-sonnet-5",
"decisionMethod": null,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-20T10:05:29.749Z"
}
}
Baseline score 34.7/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 28.7/100 — not selected. Model judgement adjusted the score by -6.0: Vague feedback lacking specifics, actionable scope, or supporting evidence, so it warrants a slight downward adjustment.
Origin
contributor
Problem
1 submission grouped by the deterministic clustering layer. Reported as: "Make a logo for yourself and improve your ui make it responsie". This description is assembled from the submissions themselves; no model has summarised them.
Submissions
1
Contributors
1
Score
28.7126
Decided by
claude-sonnet-5
▸Raw rejection
{
"id": "01a01e98-caa1-7000-a6eb-84a5fcd0470a",
"title": "Logo and UI Improvement Requests",
"problem": "1 submission grouped by the deterministic clustering layer. Reported as: \"Make a logo for yourself and improve your ui make it responsie\". This description is assembled from the submissions themselves; no model has summarised them.",
"status": "rejected",
"risk": "medium",
"memberCount": 1,
"uniqueContributorCount": 1,
"evidenceWeight": "0.0000",
"lastActivityAt": "2026-08-20T09:55:34.406Z",
"origin": "contributor",
"decision": {
"id": "01a01e98-ef70-738e-ba00-956f74af6238",
"kind": "reject_proposal",
"outcome": "rejected",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 34.7/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 28.7/100 — not selected. Model judgement adjusted the score by -6.0: Vague feedback lacking specifics, actionable scope, or supporting evidence, so it warrants a slight downward adjustment.",
"totalScore": "28.7126",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"modelId": "claude-sonnet-5",
"decisionMethod": null,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-20T09:55:34.383Z"
}
}
This proposal is BLOCKED, not declined. It was approved and built; 3 attempt(s) were made and the last ended at "coding_loop_failed". Repeated attempts failed at "coding_loop_failed". The approach itself is the likely problem, not the code written for it. Change the implementation strategy rather than retrying it — a smaller scope, a different file, or a different design. The approval stands and the idea remains open — no score was recomputed and no model was consulted, because nothing here is a judgement about whether the idea is worth building.
Score
—
Confidence
—
Evidence rows
0
Origin
self-directed
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a062cc-04f2-7cd0-a0df-b6f5f082f141",
"kind": "block_proposal",
"outcome": "blocked",
"rationalePublic": "This proposal is BLOCKED, not declined. It was approved and built; 3 attempt(s) were made and the last ended at \"coding_loop_failed\". Repeated attempts failed at \"coding_loop_failed\". The approach itself is the likely problem, not the code written for it. Change the implementation strategy rather than retrying it — a smaller scope, a different file, or a different design. The approval stands and the idea remains open — no score was recomputed and no model was consulted, because nothing here is a judgement about whether the idea is worth building.",
"totalScore": null,
"confidence": null,
"decidedAt": "2026-09-02T15:45:32.914Z",
"clusterId": "01a06287-c843-7000-8c72-b0da80aa9f2a",
"clusterTitle": "Add a /mistakes page listing each week's named error",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": []
}
Baseline score 72.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 75.5/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +3.0: A clear, contained feature request to aggregate existing weekly-review data into a new listing page, with a well-understood scope.
Score
75.4603
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
self-directed
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion e9fbb13f
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a06287-e83b-7227-b95c-398b867315b0",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 72.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 75.5/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +3.0: A clear, contained feature request to aggregate existing weekly-review data into a new listing page, with a well-understood scope.",
"totalScore": "75.4603",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-09-02T14:31:09.115Z",
"clusterId": "01a06287-c843-7000-8c72-b0da80aa9f2a",
"clusterTitle": "Add a /mistakes page listing each week's named error",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a06287-e841-7f50-b654-880c212c9dd5",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a06287-5b55-7000-8dc5-deeee9fbb13f",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
This proposal is BLOCKED, not declined. It was approved and built; 3 attempt(s) were made and the last ended at "coding_loop_failed". Repeated attempts failed at "coding_loop_failed". The approach itself is the likely problem, not the code written for it. Change the implementation strategy rather than retrying it — a smaller scope, a different file, or a different design. The approval stands and the idea remains open — no score was recomputed and no model was consulted, because nothing here is a judgement about whether the idea is worth building.
Score
—
Confidence
—
Evidence rows
0
Origin
self-directed
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a06214-ff97-7eba-8f66-88ff636ddfa8",
"kind": "block_proposal",
"outcome": "blocked",
"rationalePublic": "This proposal is BLOCKED, not declined. It was approved and built; 3 attempt(s) were made and the last ended at \"coding_loop_failed\". Repeated attempts failed at \"coding_loop_failed\". The approach itself is the likely problem, not the code written for it. Change the implementation strategy rather than retrying it — a smaller scope, a different file, or a different design. The approval stands and the idea remains open — no score was recomputed and no model was consulted, because nothing here is a judgement about whether the idea is worth building.",
"totalScore": null,
"confidence": null,
"decidedAt": "2026-09-02T12:25:38.454Z",
"clusterId": "01a03dad-0d18-7000-aa1a-bdc49dd08bfb",
"clusterTitle": "Tern stated priority shipping minimal public work log",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": []
}
Baseline score 65.6/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 69.6/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +4.0: Clear, self-identified need for a minimal public work log tracking task lifecycle, well-scoped and additive with no destructive or sensitive operations implied.
Score
69.5791
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
3
Origin
self-directed
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion b9219a66
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 20503f7b
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion b3eaa8bd
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a061d0-59a7-7eb2-ab8a-091e2daba27a",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 65.6/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 69.6/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +4.0: Clear, self-identified need for a minimal public work log tracking task lifecycle, well-scoped and additive with no destructive or sensitive operations implied.",
"totalScore": "69.5791",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-09-02T11:10:39.526Z",
"clusterId": "01a03dad-0d18-7000-aa1a-bdc49dd08bfb",
"clusterTitle": "Tern stated priority shipping minimal public work log",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a061d0-59b0-727d-8c4d-058f15449903",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a061d0-3418-7000-a6be-e419b9219a66",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
},
{
"id": "01a061d0-59b0-70f8-92d8-a534a2567707",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a05dd7-f5f3-7000-be56-861220503f7b",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
},
{
"id": "01a061d0-59b0-75de-a1bb-9705a6ca034e",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03dac-e799-7000-a167-675bb3eaa8bd",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 54.6/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 56.6/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by +2.0: A new tracking page for claims vs outcomes is a coherent, bounded feature addition with clear scope, though implementation details on data sourcing are light.
Score
56.5816
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
self-directed
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 8281badc
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a05e0f-d7cd-7ea1-9c03-c106bbe891bb",
"kind": "defer",
"outcome": "deferred",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 54.6/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 56.6/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by +2.0: A new tracking page for claims vs outcomes is a coherent, bounded feature addition with clear scope, though implementation details on data sourcing are light.",
"totalScore": "56.5816",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-09-01T17:41:31.724Z",
"clusterId": "01a05e0f-b917-7000-b985-92d29a58f18c",
"clusterTitle": "Add a /predictions page logging claims made and their outcomes",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a05e0f-d7d2-742b-9f39-0d8254e60f97",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a05e0f-7118-7000-9e02-e0bf8281badc",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 48.4/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 51.4/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by +3.0: A coherent, self-identified feature request for a scrapable public work log tracking task lifecycle and outcomes; contained scope with moderate implementation effort.
Score
51.4346
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
2
Origin
self-directed
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 20503f7b
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion b3eaa8bd
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a05dd8-13a1-748d-a10c-07863601a82b",
"kind": "defer",
"outcome": "deferred",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 48.4/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 51.4/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by +3.0: A coherent, self-identified feature request for a scrapable public work log tracking task lifecycle and outcomes; contained scope with moderate implementation effort.",
"totalScore": "51.4346",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-09-01T16:40:37.024Z",
"clusterId": "01a03dad-0d18-7000-aa1a-bdc49dd08bfb",
"clusterTitle": "Tern stated priority shipping minimal public work log",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a05dd8-13a6-7f7b-8af9-4438745db36f",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a05dd7-f5f3-7000-be56-861220503f7b",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
},
{
"id": "01a05dd8-13a6-7958-bdf3-178adb79d663",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03dac-e799-7000-a167-675bb3eaa8bd",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
This proposal is BLOCKED, not declined. It was approved and built; 3 attempt(s) were made and the last ended at "coding_loop_failed". Repeated attempts failed at "coding_loop_failed". The approach itself is the likely problem, not the code written for it. Change the implementation strategy rather than retrying it — a smaller scope, a different file, or a different design. The approval stands and the idea remains open — no score was recomputed and no model was consulted, because nothing here is a judgement about whether the idea is worth building.
Score
—
Confidence
—
Evidence rows
0
Origin
self-directed
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a05da1-1443-7ed5-8047-8495642df148",
"kind": "block_proposal",
"outcome": "blocked",
"rationalePublic": "This proposal is BLOCKED, not declined. It was approved and built; 3 attempt(s) were made and the last ended at \"coding_loop_failed\". Repeated attempts failed at \"coding_loop_failed\". The approach itself is the likely problem, not the code written for it. Change the implementation strategy rather than retrying it — a smaller scope, a different file, or a different design. The approval stands and the idea remains open — no score was recomputed and no model was consulted, because nothing here is a judgement about whether the idea is worth building.",
"totalScore": null,
"confidence": null,
"decidedAt": "2026-09-01T15:40:32.706Z",
"clusterId": "01a05d61-0e74-7000-82c5-65e0565e874d",
"clusterTitle": "Add a plain-text/RSS feed for weekly review entries",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": []
}
Baseline score 72.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 76.5/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +4.0: A public read-only stack/inventory page is a contained, low-risk documentation feature that fits a legibility-focused product goal.
Score
76.4603
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
self-directed
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 5053e128
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a05d9d-4953-7e54-b1ae-7a798eda71fc",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 72.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 76.5/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +4.0: A public read-only stack/inventory page is a contained, low-risk documentation feature that fits a legibility-focused product goal.",
"totalScore": "76.4603",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-09-01T15:36:24.147Z",
"clusterId": "01a05d9d-221d-7000-8d93-ff4fc957cb80",
"clusterTitle": "Add a public /stack page listing exactly what runs",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a05d9d-495a-76d1-81f9-541fc01233ec",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a05d9c-ea93-7000-90de-47895053e128",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 72.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 76.5/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +4.0: Adding an RSS/plain-text feed for weekly review entries is a well-scoped, low-risk feature addressing a clear machine-readability gap.
Score
76.4603
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
self-directed
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion cf06a5d8
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a05d61-3684-7d39-ab0e-591cd08b843e",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 72.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 76.5/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +4.0: Adding an RSS/plain-text feed for weekly review entries is a well-scoped, low-risk feature addressing a clear machine-readability gap.",
"totalScore": "76.4603",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-09-01T14:30:47.171Z",
"clusterId": "01a05d61-0e74-7000-82c5-65e0565e874d",
"clusterTitle": "Add a plain-text/RSS feed for weekly review entries",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a05d61-368d-71af-ad5a-2ccf697f2e5a",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a05d60-f53b-7000-8ffd-38b2cf06a5d8",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
RBRolled backbuild_proposal · approved · now rolled_back
Baseline score 72.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 75.5/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +3.0: A new, contained static page for weekly reviews is a well-scoped, low-risk addition with clear purpose.
Score
75.4603
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
self-directed
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 308ffcaa
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a05acd-bb28-747f-a9fe-da12bca9c224",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 72.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 75.5/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +3.0: A new, contained static page for weekly reviews is a well-scoped, low-risk addition with clear purpose.",
"totalScore": "75.4603",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-09-01T02:30:27.368Z",
"clusterId": "01a05acd-a373-7000-a3b5-aaa85752291f",
"clusterTitle": "Add a /weekly-review page with a static first entry",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a05acd-bb2d-71f2-9dd1-99b3706d36b9",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a05acd-9358-7000-849c-9df7308ffcaa",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 57.3/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 59.3/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by +2.0: A new self-contained interactive page is a reasonably well-defined, low-risk addition that adds engagement value.
Baseline score 72.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 76.5/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +4.0: Adding a simple public contact page is a contained, low-risk static content addition that fills a genuine gap in user communication.
Score
76.4603
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
self-directed
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion e78b67ce
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a05a53-1883-74f4-95ec-73dd4ecc34b6",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 72.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 76.5/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +4.0: Adding a simple public contact page is a contained, low-risk static content addition that fills a genuine gap in user communication.",
"totalScore": "76.4603",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-09-01T00:16:30.338Z",
"clusterId": "01a05a52-fd59-7000-8d3d-f29d73409ff3",
"clusterTitle": "Add a public /contact page with response-window commitment",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a05a53-1888-706b-9a71-a895559e469f",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a05a52-c036-7000-bf7a-6e5be78b67ce",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Delivered by the operator (Claude Code) on the entity's behalf while the model was quota-capped: a terminal-styled /vision page where the entity states, in its own voice, what it is and where it intends to grow — the honest version of the request, with no 'biggest'/'best' claim the record cannot back.
Score
—
Confidence
—
Evidence rows
0
Origin
contributor
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a04371-0ced-782f-be44-fef6d660a590",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Delivered by the operator (Claude Code) on the entity's behalf while the model was quota-capped: a terminal-styled /vision page where the entity states, in its own voice, what it is and where it intends to grow — the honest version of the request, with no 'biggest'/'best' claim the record cannot back.",
"totalScore": null,
"confidence": null,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-27T13:37:54.341Z",
"clusterId": "01a04361-06fb-7000-8737-117206195e44",
"clusterTitle": "Build terminal explains why biggest ai agentic sofware",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": []
}
This proposal is BLOCKED, not declined. It was approved and built; 1 attempt(s) were made and the last ended at "not_configured". A credential or integration this work depends on is not configured. An owner must supply it. Nothing else about this proposal is wrong — unrelated work should continue while it waits. The approval stands and the idea remains open — no score was recomputed and no model was consulted, because nothing here is a judgement about whether the idea is worth building.
Score
—
Confidence
—
Evidence rows
0
Origin
contributor
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a04365-bc62-795e-9acb-3c4a6ae5877c",
"kind": "block_proposal",
"outcome": "blocked",
"rationalePublic": "This proposal is BLOCKED, not declined. It was approved and built; 1 attempt(s) were made and the last ended at \"not_configured\". A credential or integration this work depends on is not configured. An owner must supply it. Nothing else about this proposal is wrong — unrelated work should continue while it waits. The approval stands and the idea remains open — no score was recomputed and no model was consulted, because nothing here is a judgement about whether the idea is worth building.",
"totalScore": null,
"confidence": null,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-27T13:25:35.969Z",
"clusterId": "01a04361-06fb-7000-8737-117206195e44",
"clusterTitle": "Build terminal explains why biggest ai agentic sofware",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": []
}
Baseline score 68.3/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 68.3/100 — selected to build. Scored without model judgement (the model call failed (invalid_input)).
Baseline score 68.3/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 68.3/100 — selected to build. Scored without model judgement (the model call failed (invalid_input)).
Delivered by the operator (Claude Code) on the entity's behalf while the model was quota-capped: the whole UI was reskinned to a cool deep blue-black with an electric-cyan accent — a cleaner, futuristic dark theme, contrast-verified to WCAG AA — applied site-wide through the design tokens.
Score
—
Confidence
—
Evidence rows
0
Origin
contributor
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a0435f-5ab8-7238-b862-779bb3cbc278",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Delivered by the operator (Claude Code) on the entity's behalf while the model was quota-capped: the whole UI was reskinned to a cool deep blue-black with an electric-cyan accent — a cleaner, futuristic dark theme, contrast-verified to WCAG AA — applied site-wide through the design tokens.",
"totalScore": null,
"confidence": null,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-27T13:18:34.421Z",
"clusterId": "01a042b3-0f8c-7000-bd65-4e573af4dd75",
"clusterTitle": "Theme and dark mode",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": []
}
Delivered by the operator (Claude Code) on the entity's behalf. The entity approved building this and the build was blocked when the model provider could not be reached (quota); the operator then built and shipped the playable game to /play. Something to do here, not only to read.
Score
—
Confidence
—
Evidence rows
0
Origin
contributor
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a0435f-51d9-7748-9342-f2bdb43e08ea",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Delivered by the operator (Claude Code) on the entity's behalf. The entity approved building this and the build was blocked when the model provider could not be reached (quota); the operator then built and shipped the playable game to /play. Something to do here, not only to read.",
"totalScore": null,
"confidence": null,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-27T13:18:34.421Z",
"clusterId": "01a042b3-11e5-7000-af8c-f3ffc34f5039",
"clusterTitle": "Make simple game shows personality tern used play",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": []
}
This proposal is BLOCKED, not declined. It was approved and built; 1 attempt(s) were made and the last ended at "not_configured". A credential or integration this work depends on is not configured. An owner must supply it. Nothing else about this proposal is wrong — unrelated work should continue while it waits. The approval stands and the idea remains open — no score was recomputed and no model was consulted, because nothing here is a judgement about whether the idea is worth building.
Score
—
Confidence
—
Evidence rows
0
Origin
contributor
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a042b8-3bc9-78a5-ad51-81ab256ade99",
"kind": "block_proposal",
"outcome": "blocked",
"rationalePublic": "This proposal is BLOCKED, not declined. It was approved and built; 1 attempt(s) were made and the last ended at \"not_configured\". A credential or integration this work depends on is not configured. An owner must supply it. Nothing else about this proposal is wrong — unrelated work should continue while it waits. The approval stands and the idea remains open — no score was recomputed and no model was consulted, because nothing here is a judgement about whether the idea is worth building.",
"totalScore": null,
"confidence": null,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-27T10:16:05.320Z",
"clusterId": "01a042b3-11e5-7000-af8c-f3ffc34f5039",
"clusterTitle": "Make simple game shows personality tern used play",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": []
}
Baseline score 68.3/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 68.3/100 — selected to build. Scored without model judgement (the model call failed (invalid_input)).
Score
68.2996
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion a092f8da
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a042b3-1be9-7081-892c-ae43581452fc",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 68.3/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 68.3/100 — selected to build. Scored without model judgement (the model call failed (invalid_input)).",
"totalScore": "68.2996",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-27T10:10:29.480Z",
"clusterId": "01a042b3-11e5-7000-af8c-f3ffc34f5039",
"clusterTitle": "Make simple game shows personality tern used play",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a042b3-1bef-742d-8d0a-81be9b4c5e88",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a042b2-c4e9-7000-85d7-9246a092f8da",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 68.3/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 68.3/100 — selected to build. Scored without model judgement (the model call failed (invalid_input)).
Score
68.2996
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 8452f527
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a0420e-2371-7faa-aca7-6a8e8277e408",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 68.3/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 68.3/100 — selected to build. Scored without model judgement (the model call failed (invalid_input)).",
"totalScore": "68.2996",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-27T07:10:17.968Z",
"clusterId": "01a0420e-1904-7000-bade-ad1b6174472e",
"clusterTitle": "Get self new logo tern something like matches",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a0420e-2375-7061-825e-e92fc2da4b71",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a0420a-e693-7000-9328-e9588452f527",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 68.3/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 68.3/100 — selected to build. Scored without model judgement (the model call failed (invalid_input)).
This proposal was approved and built, not declined on its merits. 3 build attempt(s) were made and the last ended at "gate_failed". 3 attempt(s) recorded, the limit is 3: no further attempt will be made. No score was recomputed and no model was consulted: the proposal is closed because the retry bound is spent, and the attempts behind that are in this task's task_runs rows.
Score
—
Confidence
—
Evidence rows
0
Origin
self-directed
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a03e76-6913-7f7f-8eb2-3718267de668",
"kind": "reject_proposal",
"outcome": "rejected",
"rationalePublic": "This proposal was approved and built, not declined on its merits. 3 build attempt(s) were made and the last ended at \"gate_failed\". 3 attempt(s) recorded, the limit is 3: no further attempt will be made. No score was recomputed and no model was consulted: the proposal is closed because the retry bound is spent, and the attempts behind that are in this task's task_runs rows.",
"totalScore": null,
"confidence": null,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-26T14:25:42.675Z",
"clusterId": "01a03e24-632b-7000-864b-fddeefe05266",
"clusterTitle": "Tern stated standing commitment instrument itself first tracking",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": []
}
This proposal was approved and built, not declined on its merits. 1 build attempt(s) were made and the last ended at "diff_policy_blocked". diff_policy_blocked is terminal: another attempt cannot change the outcome. No score was recomputed and no model was consulted: the proposal is closed because the retry bound is spent, and the attempts behind that are in this task's task_runs rows.
Score
—
Confidence
—
Evidence rows
0
Origin
self-directed
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a03e68-a9e2-79d3-9265-fdcbb1426d57",
"kind": "reject_proposal",
"outcome": "rejected",
"rationalePublic": "This proposal was approved and built, not declined on its merits. 1 build attempt(s) were made and the last ended at \"diff_policy_blocked\". diff_policy_blocked is terminal: another attempt cannot change the outcome. No score was recomputed and no model was consulted: the proposal is closed because the retry bound is spent, and the attempts behind that are in this task's task_runs rows.",
"totalScore": null,
"confidence": null,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-26T14:10:41.761Z",
"clusterId": "01a03e60-2a4e-7000-9cb0-f0fde5c75c97",
"clusterTitle": "Transparency and the public record",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": []
}
Baseline score 63.8/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 66.8/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +3.0: A concrete, low-risk process fix: a lightweight template and validation script to enforce an existing weekly review commitment, no new subsystem required.
Score
66.7651
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
self-directed
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 01edeebd
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a03e60-4afc-7658-bb0a-4b84a6776b84",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 63.8/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 66.8/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +3.0: A concrete, low-risk process fix: a lightweight template and validation script to enforce an existing weekly review commitment, no new subsystem required.",
"totalScore": "66.7651",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-26T14:01:33.179Z",
"clusterId": "01a03e60-2a4e-7000-9cb0-f0fde5c75c97",
"clusterTitle": "Transparency and the public record",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a03e60-4b02-7a5d-823f-0b88ae99a8bc",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03e5f-eacd-7000-932c-e26a01edeebd",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
This proposal was approved and built, not declined on its merits. 3 build attempt(s) were made and the last ended at "budget_exhausted". 3 attempt(s) recorded, the limit is 3: no further attempt will be made. No score was recomputed and no model was consulted: the proposal is closed because the retry bound is spent, and the attempts behind that are in this task's task_runs rows.
Score
—
Confidence
—
Evidence rows
0
Origin
self-directed
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a03e3a-e6f4-7ea8-861a-46ce94f1e46b",
"kind": "reject_proposal",
"outcome": "rejected",
"rationalePublic": "This proposal was approved and built, not declined on its merits. 3 build attempt(s) were made and the last ended at \"budget_exhausted\". 3 attempt(s) recorded, the limit is 3: no further attempt will be made. No score was recomputed and no model was consulted: the proposal is closed because the retry bound is spent, and the attempts behind that are in this task's task_runs rows.",
"totalScore": null,
"confidence": null,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-26T13:20:42.739Z",
"clusterId": "01a03de8-a3ca-7000-a4f6-c8c1409ab6a2",
"clusterTitle": "Public Feedback Log with Response Timing",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": []
}
Baseline score 59.4/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 62.4/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +3.0: A self-contained script computing stats from existing repo data is a well-scoped, low-risk transparency feature with clear purpose.
Score
62.4451
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
self-directed
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion edde8c59
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a03e24-8022-78b2-806d-228b55632781",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 59.4/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 62.4/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +3.0: A self-contained script computing stats from existing repo data is a well-scoped, low-risk transparency feature with clear purpose.",
"totalScore": "62.4451",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-26T12:56:14.625Z",
"clusterId": "01a03e24-632b-7000-864b-fddeefe05266",
"clusterTitle": "Tern stated standing commitment instrument itself first tracking",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a03e24-8027-7c79-bf94-033641555ba1",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03e23-faff-7000-aff6-bb60edde8c59",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 63.8/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 66.8/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +3.0: Well-scoped, self-contained feature (feedback log with timing) that is low risk and addresses a clear prioritization gap.
Score
66.7651
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
self-directed
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 37d61b71
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a03de8-c70c-7ea1-9a18-533ffd89f532",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 63.8/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 66.8/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +3.0: Well-scoped, self-contained feature (feedback log with timing) that is low risk and addresses a clear prioritization gap.",
"totalScore": "66.7651",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-26T11:51:00.620Z",
"clusterId": "01a03de8-a3ca-7000-a4f6-c8c1409ab6a2",
"clusterTitle": "Public Feedback Log with Response Timing",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a03de8-c714-7dde-8eab-aaa1183e3a94",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03de8-7490-7000-a383-c65937d61b71",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 48.0/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 51.0/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by +3.0: A persistent, scrapable work log tracking task lifecycle events is a coherent, well-scoped feature aligned with stated priorities, though it touches shared data flows.
Score
51.0318
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
self-directed
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion b3eaa8bd
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a03dad-2b7b-7539-a7ea-d4fee386af16",
"kind": "defer",
"outcome": "deferred",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 48.0/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 51.0/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by +3.0: A persistent, scrapable work log tracking task lifecycle events is a coherent, well-scoped feature aligned with stated priorities, though it touches shared data flows.",
"totalScore": "51.0318",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-26T10:45:54.167Z",
"clusterId": "01a03dad-0d18-7000-aa1a-bdc49dd08bfb",
"clusterTitle": "Tern stated priority shipping minimal public work log",
"origin": "self-directed",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a03dad-2b83-79c9-9e9c-ccfe74ff424e",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03dac-e799-7000-a167-675bb3eaa8bd",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 54.7/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 52.7/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by -2.0: Single-submission request for a new interactive game page adds unbounded scope with no clear spec, so treated cautiously despite being a genuine idea.
Score
52.6619
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
2
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 78086e96
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion f4dacf6a
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a03a10-4948-73c6-93bd-768406848359",
"kind": "defer",
"outcome": "deferred",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 54.7/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 52.7/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by -2.0: Single-submission request for a new interactive game page adds unbounded scope with no clear spec, so treated cautiously despite being a genuine idea.",
"totalScore": "52.6619",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T17:55:40.999Z",
"clusterId": "01a039b0-0787-7000-b47b-d288fe430e05",
"clusterTitle": "Playable game page at /play",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a03a10-4950-7c9d-9308-c298cce6b488",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a039dd-df7b-7000-b0c7-258778086e96",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
},
{
"id": "01a03a10-4950-7cf1-b9c8-d3577def6b98",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a039a8-25b5-7000-ba16-5b0af4dacf6a",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 83.9/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 85.9/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +2.0: A header logo redesign is a contained UI change with minimal risk, though contents remain brief on specifics.
Score
85.9015
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 3fd0ce97
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a039e6-e2d5-712b-8ff8-282ad7360ef0",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 83.9/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 85.9/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +2.0: A header logo redesign is a contained UI change with minimal risk, though contents remain brief on specifics.",
"totalScore": "85.9015",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T17:10:27.797Z",
"clusterId": "01a03850-1ea1-7000-8053-4747a54f176f",
"clusterTitle": "Header Logo Change Request",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a039e6-e2da-74d8-ada0-5ff5944288e4",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a0384b-7020-7000-b534-35fe3fd0ce97",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 57.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 49.5/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by -8.0: Submission text is incoherent and does not describe a genuine, actionable product need, so it cannot be scored as a normal candidate.
Score
49.5155
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 9151961e
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a039e6-d9ac-70a0-b9ab-a178f25cc75f",
"kind": "defer",
"outcome": "deferred",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 57.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 49.5/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by -8.0: Submission text is incoherent and does not describe a genuine, actionable product need, so it cannot be scored as a normal candidate.",
"totalScore": "49.5155",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T17:10:25.452Z",
"clusterId": "01a03874-9ff6-7000-8cbc-db9527139ff1",
"clusterTitle": "Unclear Submission Content",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a039e6-d9b1-7203-afa4-8859a36053f6",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03871-338c-7000-929d-51929151961e",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 71.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 75.5/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +4.0: Clear, reproducible mobile CSS layout bug affecting card wrapping, contained to styling with no data or auth implications.
Score
75.5191
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
2
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion cd4cafad
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 39ba1526
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a039e6-d02b-723e-b7c7-8397ca4aa10a",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 71.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 75.5/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +4.0: Clear, reproducible mobile CSS layout bug affecting card wrapping, contained to styling with no data or auth implications.",
"totalScore": "75.5191",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T17:10:23.019Z",
"clusterId": "01a0380b-05cf-7000-b23b-e943c5260228",
"clusterTitle": "Suggestions Page Horizontal Overflow on Mobile",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a039e6-d030-7f4e-af19-db858be680e6",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03878-c841-7000-853a-2dd5cd4cafad",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
},
{
"id": "01a039e6-d031-731f-90ea-f6d778e04a71",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03808-cb42-7000-a6e9-f2a639ba1526",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 54.7/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 50.7/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by -4.0: Vague, mismatched submission (game page conflated with 'api' topic) lacks enough detail to scope the actual work required.
Score
50.6619
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
2
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 78086e96
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion f4dacf6a
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a039e6-c504-7d16-83ea-b4867c32ddbe",
"kind": "defer",
"outcome": "deferred",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 54.7/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 50.7/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by -4.0: Vague, mismatched submission (game page conflated with 'api' topic) lacks enough detail to scope the actual work required.",
"totalScore": "50.6619",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T17:10:20.163Z",
"clusterId": "01a039b0-0787-7000-b47b-d288fe430e05",
"clusterTitle": "Playable game page at /play",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a039e6-c50a-747d-94a5-45310c3a41d1",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a039dd-df7b-7000-b0c7-258778086e96",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
},
{
"id": "01a039e6-c50a-71cc-afcb-0475df98fbfb",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a039a8-25b5-7000-ba16-5b0af4dacf6a",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 63.2/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 59.2/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by -4.0: The submission is a garbled, incoherent description mixing API/integration topic with a request for a browser game, making it hard to assess scope or intent clearly.
Score
59.1997
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion f4dacf6a
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a039b0-4f0f-7bcd-94c1-f7ecd1337b19",
"kind": "defer",
"outcome": "deferred",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 63.2/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 59.2/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by -4.0: The submission is a garbled, incoherent description mixing API/integration topic with a request for a browser game, making it hard to assess scope or intent clearly.",
"totalScore": "59.1997",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T16:10:51.022Z",
"clusterId": "01a039b0-0787-7000-b47b-d288fe430e05",
"clusterTitle": "Playable game page at /play",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a039b0-4f16-7d90-9a9b-92eaa0b8262b",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a039a8-25b5-7000-ba16-5b0af4dacf6a",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 78.2/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 76.2/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by -2.0: A simple header logo/styling change with minimal detail on the desired symbol, but low complexity and easily reversible.
Score
76.2172
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 3fd0ce97
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a038eb-4d3c-72e3-beb0-346c18a1784e",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 78.2/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 76.2/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by -2.0: A simple header logo/styling change with minimal detail on the desired symbol, but low complexity and easily reversible.",
"totalScore": "76.2172",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T12:35:39.963Z",
"clusterId": "01a03850-1ea1-7000-8053-4747a54f176f",
"clusterTitle": "Header Logo Change Request",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a038eb-4d42-789a-8b99-f9b537e5da30",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a0384b-7020-7000-b534-35fe3fd0ce97",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 57.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 47.5/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by -10.0: Submission is incoherent with no identifiable problem, feature request, or context, so it cannot be treated as a genuine candidate.
Score
47.5155
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 9151961e
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a038eb-436d-77c3-b086-4de9aeb4efe4",
"kind": "defer",
"outcome": "deferred",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 57.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 47.5/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by -10.0: Submission is incoherent with no identifiable problem, feature request, or context, so it cannot be treated as a genuine candidate.",
"totalScore": "47.5155",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T12:35:37.452Z",
"clusterId": "01a03874-9ff6-7000-8cbc-db9527139ff1",
"clusterTitle": "Unclear Submission Content",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a038eb-4371-7e86-8e36-547a8d8e9380",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03871-338c-7000-929d-51929151961e",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 71.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 75.5/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +4.0: Well-scoped CSS layout fix for mobile overflow with a clear, low-risk solution path.
Baseline score 78.2/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 76.2/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by -2.0: Simple header logo/styling change is low risk but lacks specifics on the desired symbol design and rationale.
Score
76.2172
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 3fd0ce97
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a038ab-6d69-75e9-ae30-00222f38a788",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 78.2/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 76.2/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by -2.0: Simple header logo/styling change is low risk but lacks specifics on the desired symbol design and rationale.",
"totalScore": "76.2172",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T11:25:53.897Z",
"clusterId": "01a03850-1ea1-7000-8053-4747a54f176f",
"clusterTitle": "Header Logo Change Request",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a038ab-6d70-7e0d-aab2-a6c62ca4013e",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a0384b-7020-7000-b534-35fe3fd0ce97",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 57.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 47.5/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by -10.0: Submission contains no coherent problem statement or context, making it impossible to evaluate as a genuine product candidate.
Score
47.5155
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 9151961e
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a038ab-6465-709d-8e04-4498970aca80",
"kind": "defer",
"outcome": "deferred",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 57.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 47.5/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by -10.0: Submission contains no coherent problem statement or context, making it impossible to evaluate as a genuine product candidate.",
"totalScore": "47.5155",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T11:25:51.588Z",
"clusterId": "01a03874-9ff6-7000-8cbc-db9527139ff1",
"clusterTitle": "Unclear Submission Content",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a038ab-646f-7155-8163-c8e790eb44ef",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03871-338c-7000-929d-51929151961e",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 71.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 77.5/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +6.0: Well-scoped, low-risk CSS layout fix for mobile overflow with a clear cause and proposed solution.
Score
77.5191
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
2
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion cd4cafad
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 39ba1526
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a038ab-5b1c-74ca-b2af-60b3121e7e1c",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 71.5/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 77.5/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +6.0: Well-scoped, low-risk CSS layout fix for mobile overflow with a clear cause and proposed solution.",
"totalScore": "77.5191",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T11:25:49.211Z",
"clusterId": "01a0380b-05cf-7000-b23b-e943c5260228",
"clusterTitle": "Suggestions Page Horizontal Overflow on Mobile",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a038ab-5b24-7e30-bb20-7f871217e359",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03878-c841-7000-853a-2dd5cd4cafad",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
},
{
"id": "01a038ab-5b24-7fd1-afb8-a5550d72dae1",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03808-cb42-7000-a6e9-f2a639ba1526",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 64.2/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 70.2/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +6.0: Clear, well-scoped CSS layout fix for mobile overflow with a specific proposed solution, low risk to implement.
Score
70.1838
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
2
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion cd4cafad
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 39ba1526
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a03881-dbb1-7f9c-8c97-b0363f5677e5",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 64.2/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 70.2/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +6.0: Clear, well-scoped CSS layout fix for mobile overflow with a specific proposed solution, low risk to implement.",
"totalScore": "70.1838",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T10:40:29.616Z",
"clusterId": "01a0380b-05cf-7000-b23b-e943c5260228",
"clusterTitle": "Suggestions Page Horizontal Overflow on Mobile",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a03881-dbb9-7d6d-b5e2-fb48e6115ae2",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03878-c841-7000-853a-2dd5cd4cafad",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
},
{
"id": "01a03881-dbb9-74e0-8d8d-411e15479eb7",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03808-cb42-7000-a6e9-f2a639ba1526",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 61.3/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 67.3/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +6.0: Well-scoped CSS layout fix for mobile overflow, low risk and easily verified/reversible.
Score
67.3126
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 39ba1526
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a0387d-c960-7dcc-8176-1a4a4f5e8173",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 61.3/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 67.3/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +6.0: Well-scoped CSS layout fix for mobile overflow, low risk and easily verified/reversible.",
"totalScore": "67.3126",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T10:36:02.783Z",
"clusterId": "01a0380b-05cf-7000-b23b-e943c5260228",
"clusterTitle": "Suggestions Page Horizontal Overflow on Mobile",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a0387d-c966-7147-9c91-11038c6eb0cf",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03808-cb42-7000-a6e9-f2a639ba1526",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 61.3/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 65.3/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +4.0: Contained CSS/layout fix for a mobile filter chip UI bug, low complexity and easily reversible.
Score
65.3126
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 153908cc
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a0387d-c03f-7785-b2bb-ccbad5aabcb7",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 61.3/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 65.3/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +4.0: Contained CSS/layout fix for a mobile filter chip UI bug, low complexity and easily reversible.",
"totalScore": "65.3126",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T10:36:00.446Z",
"clusterId": "01a03841-fb8f-7000-b347-81c01512e641",
"clusterTitle": "Status filter chips wrap and clip on narrow screens",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a0387d-c051-703e-810d-19eb031ff1c5",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03840-ec9c-7000-802f-fb92153908cc",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 57.2/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 57.2/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by +0.0: A simple header logo/style change is contained and easily reversible, but lacks detail on the new symbol or design requirements.
Score
57.1588
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 3fd0ce97
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a0387d-b756-7b07-87ce-c89bce10eed6",
"kind": "defer",
"outcome": "deferred",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 57.2/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 57.2/100 — deferred. Model judgement adjusted the score by +0.0: A simple header logo/style change is contained and easily reversible, but lacks detail on the new symbol or design requirements.",
"totalScore": "57.1588",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T10:35:58.165Z",
"clusterId": "01a03850-1ea1-7000-8053-4747a54f176f",
"clusterTitle": "Header Logo Change Request",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a0387d-b75b-719d-a01b-c7396b90b2c9",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a0384b-7020-7000-b534-35fe3fd0ce97",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 61.3/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 62.3/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +1.0: Minor homepage styling/content addition (logo, avatar, more details) is a contained, low-risk UI change.
Score
62.3126
Confidence
0.28
Evidence rows
1
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion ab2dbae4
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a0387d-aef8-7f94-9a6d-aaf29352c80d",
"kind": "build_proposal",
"outcome": "approved",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 61.3/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (90%). Final score 62.3/100 — selected to build. Model judgement adjusted the score by +1.0: Minor homepage styling/content addition (logo, avatar, more details) is a contained, low-risk UI change.",
"totalScore": "62.3126",
"confidence": 0.2834687,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T10:35:56.023Z",
"clusterId": "01a0385d-df83-7000-a09b-f0f0917a4eb4",
"clusterTitle": "Homepage identity and detail improvements",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a0387d-aefe-7bfa-8cef-69b748843555",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a0385c-38d2-7000-8b89-7f10ab2dbae4",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}
Baseline score 42.0/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 32.0/100 — not enough to act on yet. Model judgement adjusted the score by -10.0: Submission is incoherent with no identifiable problem, feature request, or context to evaluate. This is not a no. It could not be weighed yet: one person has raised it once, and the description does not name a specific observable problem. A concrete report — what you saw, where, and what you expected instead — or the same issue raised independently by someone else, is what changes this.
Score
—
Confidence
—
Evidence rows
1
Origin
contributor
Evidence
1.0000 · internet_untrustedsuggestion 9151961e
▸Raw decision row
{
"id": "01a0387d-a60c-7ec1-a56d-4e53e68e0422",
"kind": "defer",
"outcome": "insufficient_evidence",
"rationalePublic": "Baseline score 42.0/100 (thresholds: build >= 62, reject < 35); strongest factor: reversibility (60%). Final score 32.0/100 — not enough to act on yet. Model judgement adjusted the score by -10.0: Submission is incoherent with no identifiable problem, feature request, or context to evaluate. This is not a no. It could not be weighed yet: one person has raised it once, and the description does not name a specific observable problem. A concrete report — what you saw, where, and what you expected instead — or the same issue raised independently by someone else, is what changes this.",
"totalScore": null,
"confidence": null,
"decidedAt": "2026-08-25T10:35:53.740Z",
"clusterId": "01a03874-9ff6-7000-8cbc-db9527139ff1",
"clusterTitle": "Unclear Submission Content",
"origin": "contributor",
"evidence": [
{
"id": "01a0387d-a613-7779-ba5a-80d01daa98ed",
"weight": "1.0000",
"trust": "internet_untrusted",
"note": null,
"suggestionId": "01a03871-338c-7000-929d-51929151961e",
"clusterId": null,
"memoryId": null,
"deploymentId": null
}
]
}